The Palm Beach Post · West Palm Beach, Florida · · Page 14
It's a cheesy defense, but it's plausible
Frank Cerabino
Transcript
May it please the court.
Your honor, ladies and gentlemen of the jury and assorted spectators who have gathered here today for this virtual hearing in the court of public opinion.
I rise in support of Lacqetta Monroe, the 23-year-old mother who forgot her child at the Chuck E. Cheese west of Boca Raton during the weekend.
The facts of this case are not in dispute: The boy, Michael, had just celebrated his sixth birthday at this haven of kiddie gatherings, and through an unfortunate series of bad assumptions, he was left behind while Ms. Monroe and the rest of the birthday entourage drove off into the night.
Little Michael's abandonment was discovered by the employees of Chuck E. Cheese as they were closing at 10 p.m.
Ms. Monroe went to bed that evening thinking that Michael had gone home with his grandmother, where he would be spending the night.
It would be a bad assumption she would believe until authorities tracked her down the next day.
OK, clearly, Ms. Monroe could have been a more thorough chaperone on the evening.
"Michael," she might have asked at some point, "how did you enjoy your party, Michael? . . . Michael? . . . Michael?"
Yes, it is not typical to lose track of the birthday boy at the birthday party.
But ladies and gentlemen, who among us can say what sort of mental condition we'd be in after two hours of screaming kids in a Chuck E. Cheese?
Which one of us has ever crawled through the sky tubes, staggered among the din of games and smiled wanly at the appearance of the big stuffed singing rat?
How many of us can say that we would have all our own adult mental faculties after a concentrated dose at the self-proclaimed "Birthday Capital of the Universe?"
Yes, ladies and gentlemen, you could call this the Chuck E. Cheese Defense, if you wish — a form of temporary insanity caused by a soft-drink-addled, kiddie-screeching environment that has a base-line noise level approaching that of a space shuttle launch.
If Ms. Monroe had left her child behind at a public library, for example, I would not be speaking today.
But ladies and gentleman, I have been one of those parents who have hosted a birthday party at a Chuck E. Cheese. And while I didn't leave my child behind, I certainly experienced what could only be described as a feeling of great relief to step outside after the party.
I do not say this to criticize Chuck E. Cheese, but merely to point out that while this sort of atmosphere is thrilling to a child, its effects on an adult is something that hasn't been fully studied in the psychiatric literature.
So, let us not jump so fast to condemn Ms. Monroe.
Instead, let's look at motive.
What could possibly be her motive to leave her son behind?
Knowingly leaving a child behind would mean that at some point in the very near future you might be summoned back to Chuck E. Cheese.
Hurrying back to Chuck E. Cheese is the last thing an adult wants to do after getting out of a kid's party there.
And finally, let's talk about the potential harm done. And let's be honest here.
Little Michael wasn't left behind on a sinking boat, in a burning building or inside a car with all the windows rolled up on a hot day.
Leaving a child behind at Chuck E. Cheese is like forgetting your husband at T's Lounge.
Somehow, you've got to figure, they'll make the best of it.