Democrat and Chronicle · Rochester, New York · · Page 58

Marineland's whales are magnificent – too bad they're stuck in such cramped quarters

Lee Krenis More

Transcript

At Marineland in Niagara Falls, Ontario, it's business as usual — no protesters, no pickets, no murmurs about Free Willy.

Four killer whales perform five 15-minute shows per day to packed, enthusiastic crowds. Yet their tank is only 75 feet long and 25 feet wide — less than half the size of an Olympic swimming pool.

"That's horrible," said Naomi Rose, a marine mammal scientist for the Humane Society of the United States, when she looked up these dimensions for me. "That's really bad."

Canada, she explained, has no equivalent to the U.S. Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972, which sets minimum standards for American facilities.

By comparison, Sea World's four parks are well above American standards, with orca facilities three or four times as large as Marineland's.

Marineland keeps three adult whales (the largest is Kandu, at 10,000 pounds) and a juvenile in the main pool and two round adjoining pools, each of which is 25 feet in diameter.

I called Marineland to verify these numbers, but no one, including owner John Holer, would talk to me, despite repeated efforts.

So I went to Marineland Thursday to see for myself. What I found, two hours and $19 later, was a main whale tank about the length of two backyard swimming pools, with an ersatz medieval stage set in the background. Above the stage is a giant sign for Fuji film.

I also found a store with dozens of whale trinkets — $1.99 for a porcelain thimble set, $4.99 for a plastic blow-up of Kandu, $18.99 for a midnight blue ceramic whale — and a show that didn't measure up to its own advertising.

In Marineland's TV ads, whales leap in tandem, and hurl themselves out of the water and onto the side of the pool. They didn't do that at the show I saw, although one whale did jump up and plant a surprisingly delicate kiss on the cheek of a volunteer from the crowd.

Still, the whales are magnificent — sleek and shiny, with a large repertoire of tricks. They leap out of the water, dive, roll over, turn in circles, stick out their tongues and wave their flippers.

But they are domesticated, subdued. Before the show, they float motionless, swim in circles and often push their bodies up the walls of the tank as if they are trying to get out.

In the first few minutes of the movie Free Willy, you see a group of orcas swimming and playing in the ocean. They are fast, powerful and breathtakingly beautiful.

To see such whales do tricks in a small tank is like watching a caged bear in diapers dance on command. They're still wonderful creatures, but something essential has been lost. ❑

[Photo caption] Killer whales perform at Marineland in Niagara Falls, Ontario. The park keeps four whales in three pools. (LIBRARY)