San Francisco Chronicle · San Francisco, California · · Page 4
Mr. Cheese Nibbles at a Palace
By Allan Temko, Architecture Critic
Transcript
Chuck E. Cheese has been hopping about the Bay Area at such a rate that the robotic pizza parlor rodent — the Silicon Valley brainchild of the same ingenious people who brought you Atari — was bound to land on a traditional community such as Alameda.
The packaged environment of a Chuck E. Cheese Pizza Time Theatre would be outlandish in any downtown with a strongly established character, but the center of Alameda happens to contain a treasure of historic monuments, including a great neo-classical high school that was barely saved from destruction in the 1970s.
Chuck E. Cheese wants to plant his ersatz paws in the midst of such a genuine place, making his nest in the landmark Alameda Theatre of 1932.
This elegant building is one of the late Timothy Pflueger's finest Art Deco movie houses. Although not so grand as the superbly restored Paramount in Oakland, it's generally more accomplished than the slightly earlier Castro in San Francisco.
The Alameda could be restored to mint condition without much trouble. Now vacant, the charming auditorium was misused for a time as a roller rink, so it would need new seats and some redoing. Fortunately, during the roller rink period, the walls, staircase and railings of the lobby were protected by barriers, and it remains largely intact as a minor chef-d'oeuvre of Moderne detailing.
The ceiling of the lobby is an especially brilliant stroke of indirect lighting, or rather an architectural lighting fixture in itself, with frosted glass separating overlaid sculptural surfaces, so that the space is illuminated in a gently spectacular way.
The creamy exterior, with its curving uprights and abstract reliefs, remains an extraordinary period piece that harmonizes perfectly with its neighbors in a downtown that has kept its scale and mood of half a century ago.
Mr. Cheese's keepers claim that the exterior of the building would scarcely be disturbed. There's reason to believe this, if only because this whiz-bang, show-biz chain, specializing in what Lewis Mumford called "purposeless consumption," doesn't give a rap about the outsides of its buildings. They blend into shopping centers like lichen on rocks.
There are in fact non-historic parts of Alameda where a post-historic, computerized food-cum-amusement operation would be quite correct. Alamedans could drive across the blacktop tundras of the South Shore Shopping Center, for instance, to savor assembly-line pizzas whose mucilaginous consistency is not too different from Wrigley's, exactly as Pleasanton residents cross the vaster parking lots of the mammoth Stoneridge shopping and office complex.
Architecturally, if one can use the word in connection with such establishments, the Pizza Time Theatres remain almost indistinguishable from their neighbors even in a better-than-average shopping center such as the Willows in Concord.
It is on the inside that a real collision occurs with historic values. See, Pizza Time Theatre personnel say, how the little children and their parents love the place. And, so help me, the computerized dummies are programmed to be endearing to young and old.
The effect of the automatons is almost as hypnotic as the token-fed computer games — the great source of cash in this business — which blink and flash, click and buzz, in darkened adjacent spaces, sometimes strung with synthetic jungle foliage, which eerily suggests children's gambling casinos. Pizza Time's success demands this electronic entertainment. To that end, the Alameda City Council has voted to rescind an ordinance banning video games near residences; there will be a second vote on the issue July 5. Then the pizza company must apply for a use permit to take over the theater.
In the theater, there's Disneyish Chuck himself, the cuddly rat who loves pizza cheese. And Mr. Munch, the purple pizza-eater from Outer Space. Jasper T. Jowls is a hound dog. The long-beaked Warblettes are a trio of what appear to be crows. Madame Oink, this year's guest star, is a melodious, overdressed sow.
The only pseudo-human figure is the chef Pasqually — get it? — who as a mechanical stage Italian bears as much relation to real Italians as the pizza on sale, at $5.35 and up, does to the genuine article in Naples or Rome.
This is phenomenal technological folk art. Every eight minutes, unless they do a Happy Birthday routine in between, this cast goes into a musical act, with the soundtrack on full volume.
Lights flash. Drumsticks beat against the backs of frying pans. Flags wave. The Stars and Stripes, of course, and the California Bear Flag, Chuck E. Cheese's own banner — and, in deference to the pseudo-ethnic piece de resistance on the menu, the green, white and red of Italy.
That's all understandable. What's puzzling is that the Stars and Bars of the Confederacy waves beside them.
The kids hardly pay attention. They consume parts of the food, and run back to the games. After they run out of bonus tokens that come with pizzas or soft drinks (or the beer and wine their parents can order), they put dollars in change machines that produce Chuck E. Cheese tokens, worth a quarter each, that are imprinted "In Pizza We Trust."
The video menu includes Zero Q-bert, Astro Blaster Kangeroo, Centipede, Digdub and TRON. Smaller kids prefer to use their tokens for the mechanical toys in Pasqually's Play-N-Space: riding on animals and motorcycles, in space craft and helicopters, and covered wagons. Skeeball, which also costs tokens, seems a relief after a while.
Not since Charlie Chaplin was force-fed by a machine in "Modern Times" have robots helped to cram food into humans so relentlessly — and Pizza Time's formula is easy to swallow.
But put it somewhere else.
Alameda's historic Art Deco movie palace, more suited to Mr. Chaplin than Mr. Cheese, shouldn't be gutted.
[Photo caption] Token-fed games for children in rooms strung with synthetic jungle foliage are the great source of cash in this business
[Photo caption] Chuck E. Cheese has grand ideas about selling pizza inside the landmark Alameda Theatre