Arizona Republic · Phoenix, Arizona · · Page 81

Phoenix pizza chain named in $33 million court case

Transcript

— PHOENIX, from page E1

They claim Peter Piper broke promises to provide better support than Pistol Pete's and barred them from opening the third restaurant.

Further, they say the merger gave Peter Piper access to the Campbell's financial and marketing information. They complained it was unfair to pay royalties to Peter Piper when they weren't getting any support and charged that Peter Piper was trying to run them out of business.

"They were the only Pistol Pete's franchises left in the company," said Kerry Blair, the Houston attorney who is teaming with Mitchell to handle the case. "They've destroyed whatever value was left in Pistol Pete's."

Joe Pedersen, Peter Piper's chief executive, said Friday that his company was "blindsided" by the lawsuit. He said the company had not been served with the case, but that Peter Piper heard about it secondhand because it was being publicized.

Pedersen said Peter Piper doesn't want to add stores in El Paso as the Campbells wish. The Campbells, he said, wanted to stop paying franchise royalties to Peter Piper after it bought Pistol Pete's.

"We didn't buy the company so we wouldn't make any money," Pedersen said. "Their whole foundation on this is one pizza place can't buy another pizza place."

Both sides say there were negotiations for Peter Piper to buy the Campbell's restaurants. Blair said Peter Piper didn't make any "good-faith offers" for the business. Pedersen said the couple demanded "double what it was worth."

The lawsuit also claims that Peter Piper is planning to go public and that aggressive expansion of its market share is "crucial to their game plan."

Pedersen said Peter Piper has no such plans.

"This is fraught with inaccuracies," he said of the lawsuit.

The Campbells are asking for a minimum of $11 million in damages to be tripled under terms of antitrust laws. They're also asking for exemplary damages and an injunction stopping Peter Piper from enforcing any franchise agreements.

A side issue is what appears to be a battle for public opinion. The Campbells, self-described little guys, have the public relations agency spinning their story. The law firm also includes former Texas Gov. Ann Richards and former Treasury Secretary Lloyd Bentsen on its staff.

Blair said Mitchell, a Democrat who served Maine in the Senate, will be co-counsel. He didn't know how much it cost to hire the public relations firm and he wouldn't say how much he's charging.

"We're not in the habit of taking contingency cases," he said.

Blair said the Campbells decided to roll out the artillery when Peter Piper threatened to attack them with "New York lawyers." Pedersen thinks the Campbells are trying to sway public opinion.

"It's a classic example of them trying to use the media to embarrass the franchisor and get them to acquiesce to demands they might have," he said.