Clarion-Ledger · Jackson, Mississippi · · Page 19
To pizza partners, it's case closed: Their Chuck E. Cheese firm is open
By DENNIS CAUCHON, Clarion-Ledger Business Writer
Transcript
Sometimes when Bill Melvin answers the phone at his Chuck E. Cheese restaurant, the caller wants to buy equipment the bankrupt pizza company doesn't need any longer.
Only trouble is, the Chuck E. Cheese franchise in Jackson isn't bankrupt. People just think it is.
"This thing is like a nightmare," said Melvin, co-owner of Chuck E. Cheese, located off I-55 North.
Chuck E. Cheese's national company, Pizza Time Theaters, filed for protection under bankruptcy laws on March 29, 1984. "We felt an immediate drop-off in business," said co-owner Richard Ciaccio.
The pair of former McDonald's executives have been struggling ever since to assure the public that Chuck E. Cheese in Jackson is still open for business and can survive without the parent company.
"The public doesn't realize there is a large difference between the franchisee and franchisor," Ciaccio said.
To get rights to Chuck E. Cheese restaurants in Mississippi and Arkansas, Melvin and Ciaccio paid the parent company a lump sum plus a percentage of revenues as a royalty. The partners, who considered the chain's recipe dangerous to taste buds, retained the rights to prepare its own pizza.
According to Melvin and Ciaccio, their 385-seat Chuck E. Cheese did tremendously in its first 20 months and, though now suffering, is still in the black.
"It's a very simple story," Melvin said. "We did our part and were abandoned by the national company."
The national company, based in California, was the brainchild of Nolan Bushnell, the technical whiz behind Atari and, to many, the father of the video game.
Bushnell sold Atari and conceived of a new enterprise: Chuck E. Cheese's Pizza Time Theatre, where video games, mascots and modern technology create a Disneyland atmosphere surrounding a pizza parlor.
The concept was an enormous hit with children. The Jackson restaurant still does 100 birthday parties a week. "We're really in the kiddie business. They're the backbone of our business," Ciaccio said.
Ciaccio and Melvin, who met while working at McDonald's in Cincinnati 15 years ago, decided Chuck E. Cheese was the concept of the future. They bought franchise rights to Mississippi and Arkansas, gave up their jobs, uprooted their families, moved to a new state and jumped into business.
The chain expanded to 250 stores before poor management decisions — including spending too much money developing video games and not enough on the restaurant business — sent the national company into a tailspin, according to Melvin and Ciaccio. Following bankruptcy, a company-owned store in Biloxi closed and the chain shrunk to about 150 restaurants, mostly surviving franchises.
"This shows the irony and pluses of being a franchisee. You're all in it together," Ciaccio said.
Being in it together gives franchisees many of the advantages of large size, ranging from bulk purchases to national advertising. Chuck E. Cheese franchisees suddenly had these advantages taken from them.
No more national advertising. No more Chuck E. Cheese dolls or wrist-
See Pizza, page 9B
[Photo caption] DIANNE LAAKSO/The Clarion-Ledger Chuck E. Cheese's owners, Bill Melvin, left, and Richard Ciaccio, pose with the pizza restaurant's namesake. Bankruptcy rumors have hurt, but the owners have no plans to leave Jackson.