The Orlando Sentinel · Orlando, Florida · · Page 54
Area's Inventors in World of Their Own
By Brad Kuhn, Of the Sentinel Staff
Transcript
Paul McCartney's head sits on a shelf, near what appears to be a rubber chicken with its head blown off.
Dozens of eyes peer from the shadows, waiting for faces that are being formed in some jars by the door.
In a distant corner, a man silently paints, taking orders from a skinny guy named Air, who is sweating to the oldies in a bird suit and singing along to music made by dancing bears and a gorilla called Fatz.
Welcome to the wacky world of Aaron “Air” Fechter, 39, an inventor who introduced himself to Orlando in the 1970s as “The Mad Scientist” of WDBO-AM (580). He attracted international attention during the gasoline crunch, promoting a car he said could get 90 miles from a gallon of fuel.
But what Fechter may be best known for is Billy Bob, the animated mascot made famous by ShowBiz Pizza Place and the Rock-afire Explosion, an all-critter band led by Fatz and a furry surfer named Beach Bear.
Fechter is one of an eclectic breed of entrepreneurs known as inventors. No one knows how many there are in Central Florida because they tend to keep to themselves. But the fruits of their labor are plentiful enough to support more than a dozen patent lawyers and a half dozen inventor-assistance services.
In addition to Billy Bob and Fatz, other famous Central Florida inventions are Nautilus exercise equipment, X-14 mildew remover, Hawaiian Tropic, Panama Jack and Native Tan suntan products, and the signs on many fast-food delivery vehicles.
But success stories are the exception, not the rule, said James Simon, a patent lawyer with Holland & Knight in Orlando. Of the dozens of inventions brought to Central Florida patent lawyers every month, less than 10 percent make it to the patent application phase. And the ones that make money are barely a statistical blip.
“You'd be surprised how many ideas people come up with that are great, except that it's going to cost $3 to make it and you can only sell it for $1,” said Warren Franz, a patent and trademark lawyer who represents Fechter. “You come in with an idea, I get you a patent. Now what have you got? An idea and a patent.
“Unless there is money changing hands, you're just wasting your time.”
Fechter tried and failed with a number of inventions before he came up with Billy Bob and friends. Most of those ideas are gathering dust in the basement of his downtown Orlando warehouse.
Like a lot of inventors, he found experts aplenty — for a price. The experience, he said, soured him on the patent process.
“All of these companies for inventors mostly just want inventors' savings,” Fechter said. “They do patent searches. They have engineers. They'll do studies to help expand your invention. They do everything but help you make money.”
Robert Trent, regional director for Invention Submission Corp. of Pittsburgh, said investor-assistance companies often are misunderstood.
“We do not evaluate ideas or inventions,” he said. “If someone asks us if their idea is crazy, we will offer that much. But we don't think our opinion is anything more than that.”
Trent said that, for $500, his company offers little more than idea packaging. At an additional charge, Invention Submission also will help market an idea to manufacturers.
Fechter paid one such company $700 to help him patent an electronic computer relay. In return, he received a study he found to be essentially worthless.
“We were admittedly $10,000 away from reaching the patenting and marketing point,” he said. “But they should have told me that relay was a big waste of time and money.”
They didn't tell me that. They didn't tell me anything. And I went back to the drawing board and started working on it some more, not knowing it was a dead-end.”
He also bombed with a pool-cleaning tool and a bug light. The fuel-efficient car — named Jutta [pronounced Ewe-ta] after a German woman he was dating at the time — also was a bust. The car, which looks like a go-cart on steroids, is gathering dust in the basement of Fechter's robotics plant. He said he just can't bring himself to get rid of it.
And then there's the McCartney head. Built on a whim, as a tribute to Fechter's favorite rock star, it was his most ambitious animation project. He commissioned three sculptors and hired one of the robot technicians who helped assemble Abraham Lincoln for Walt Disney's 1964 World's Fair exhibit. The project was shelved, however, when money got tight.
PATENT NOT TICKET TO WEALTH
“Inventors are the backbone of our country, the unsung heroes,” said Oscar Mastin, spokesman for the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office in Washington. “But you really have to think through an invention and make sure it's something the public needs and wants.”
That's what William Elmer of Winter Park did. While working as a consultant to fast-food restaurants in the 1980s, Elmer noticed that companies offering home delivery typically had trouble storing their car-top delivery signs. He designed and patented signs that would stack neatly together.
Elmer now has eight patented sign designs and has shipped hundreds of thousands of signs internationally.
“The hardest thing for me was to quit talking about how I was going to do something and listen to the marketplace,” Elmer said.
The U.S. Patent Office issued 2,114 patents in Florida last year, about 2 percent of the 109,728 patents handed out nationwide.
Most of those patents — about 75 percent — were to researchers working for big manufacturers such as Martin Marietta, Harris Corp. or Westinghouse. Universities and nonprofit think tanks accounted for another 2 percent. The remaining 23 percent, or about 25,000 patents, were issued to private inventors, mostly for everyday items like fasteners and fishing lures.
The patent office was formed in the 1700s to coax inventors into sharing their ideas in return for a promise of exclusive use for a limited time, typically 15 years.
“A patent is really a franchise,” Mastin said. “It makes available scientific information that inventors would not have disclosed without some incentive.”
Fechter said that the knuckle-busting reality of business makes such an incentive practically worthless. And because of his brush with an invention broker, he said, he has not tried to patent any more of his ideas. All of his characters, however, are registered trademarks.
Patents can cost more than $5,000 in application and legal fees, and some do little more than register a specific design, allowing others to produce like products that perform the same function.
Design patents are less expensive and easier to obtain than utility patents, which protect the underlying technology. But they are of almost no practical value, said Carl Napolitano, an engineer studying to become a patent agent.
Napolitano compared design patents to books published by a vanity press. They look nice but have little [cut off]