Boca Raton News · Boca Raton, Florida · · Page 11
Sales at video centers have sharply declined
By Sharman Stein, Orlando Sentinel
Transcript
Pizza has acquired more snap, crackle and pop than breakfast cereal. Appearing at Pizza Time Theaters and ShowBiz Pizza Places nationwide, Chuck E. Cheese, Billy Bob and their character-cohorts have turned a slice of cheese and sauce into family entertainment, complete with video games, music and large-screen TVs.
Is this multimillion-dollar business a fad, or is it a permanent part of the American fast-food landscape? ShowBiz vice president Paul Pendergast believes there will be a market for pizza entertainment centers "as long as kids are being born."
"The financial community is less optimistic. After explosive sales and profits for the first few years, the two major restaurant-entertainment chains have posted declining sales and sharp losses for the past several quarters. Securities analysts are starting to wonder if Chuck E. Cheese and his counterparts are close to short-circuiting.
At issue is the staying power of restaurants that rely on electronic wizardry to draw in customers for food that frequently has been described as mediocre at best, but far from cheap.
The attraction for adults is almost nil. The food is priced to cover the cost of the entertainment, and the video games require a steady stream of quarters.
"How long will kids go there to play the games with more and more video players at home?" asked Kenneth Gassman, an analyst with First Wheat Securities in Richmond, Va.
Competition has also hurt. Pizza Time and ShowBiz have competed neck and neck in many cities, drawing on the same potential customers and hurting both operations. Video-game parlors have also proliferated. Pizza Time has announced that it will close 10 units this year.
Pizza Time franchisee Bill Smith sold back to the company three of his four restaurants in North Carolina because the cities were too small to support both Pizza Time and ShowBiz operations.
"People get tired with the concept," Smith said. "They need a more reasonable price, a broader food product, and more games."
Denny Moran, an analyst with A.G. Edwards in St. Louis, said everyone who entered the industry is having problems, even though it is extremely new. "It's faddish," he said.
Even the analysts most optimistic about the family entertainment concept believe it cannot continue the way it is now.
"The easy part is over," said Ron Miller, a vice president of corporate finance for Raymond, James and Associates in St. Petersburg, Fla. "It has to change and adapt to survive." Miller helped two franchisees of Pizza Time go public.
"Video games have been placed ahead of food on the concept people will pay a premium price for average food," Miller said. "New games will bring people back for awhile — but they won't keep coming back."
Pizza Time Theatre Inc., home of Chuck E. Cheese, was the brainchild of video-game entrepreneur Nolan Bushnell, who marketed the first successful video game as president of Atari Inc. The first restaurant opened in San Jose, Calif., in 1978. Most of the approximately 200 units are concentrated in Florida, California and Texas.
When Bushnell sold Atari to Warner Communications in 1976, he agreed not to compete in the video-games business for seven years. That agreement is up Oct. 1. — and the entire video-game industry is waiting to see what Bushnell has up his sleeves. The new games are expected to be introduced into Pizza Time restaurants before Christmas, and they are expected to draw crowds.
"If Bushnell's new games are at the forefront of the next generation of video games, he is well positioned to make Pizza Time extremely successful," said Clive Smith, a video analyst with the Yankee Group in Boston. "It all depends on the competition."
ShowBiz Pizza Place, which entered the market in 1980, professes not to be scared of anything Bushnell is doing. Its emphasis is on animated robot characters created by Creative Engineering Inc. of Orlando. The characters are designed to appeal to a slightly older audience.
Creative Engineering owns 20 percent of ShowBiz. The majority owner is Brock Hotel Corp. of Topeka, Kan., the largest franchiser of Holiday Inns. There are approximately 150 ShowBiz company stores and 30 franchises.
"We think the overall concept is viable and durable," Pendergast said. "If the company can keep the entertainment fresh, people will continue to seek out indoor amusement parks serving good food."
In an interview recently in the Wall Street Journal, company president Robert Brock said ShowBiz sales have improved during the past six weeks due to the shakeout among competitors in the pizza entertainment business. He blamed the recession and competition for declining sales of the past year and predicted that his competitiors would close 50 to 60 stores this year.
The man behind the ShowBiz robots, Aaron Fechter of Creative Engineering, said Bushnell's new games, no matter how good, will not emphasize the same kind of ongoing entertainment that his characters provide.
And if ShowBiz wants the new games, Fechter said, Bushnell will sell them.
"Everything has to change," Fechter said, "the characters, the shows — maybe even someday, there won't be any video games."
Pizza Time is placing high hopes on Bushnell, but it also is concentrating on improved food and service. Jim Morgan, assistant treasurer at Pizza Time, said the restaurants face the challenge of attracting a broader market. "Our feeling is that kids always want to come, but the veto is held by the parent. There's not that much fun for mom and dad."
The future will show that the concept is still sound, Morgan said, although modifications are needed. [cut off]