Detroit Free Press · Detroit, Michigan · · Page 64

Shakeout in kiddie pizza places

Transcript

PIZZA TIME, from Page 1F

Inc. founder Nolan Bushnell. After Bushnell sold Atari to Warner Communications in 1976, Atari scored profits of $323.3 million in 1982, only to see $539 million in losses and more than 2,500 layoffs in 1983.

Pizza Time's financial problems have been accompanied by top management changes at its Sunnyvale, Calif., headquarters. Joseph Keenan resigned as president in September 1983. Former president Randall Pike stepped down in March, and co-founder Bushnell resigned in February.

PIZZA TIME is not alone in the pizza/entertainment center shakeout.

K mart Corp., which entered the market on a trial basis in 1982 with two Abra K Dabra restaurants, closed them in late 1983, said corporate spokeswoman Barbara Palazzolo.

ShowBiz Pizza Place, run by Dallas-based Brock Hotel Corp., also expects to report a 1983 loss.

Securities analysts, restaurant executives and customers say the concept was hurt by expensive but poor quality food in some locations, too many similar restaurants in the same market, bored parents, and the changing tastes of the two- to 11-year-old children who make up the bulk of the company's customers.

Pizza Time has 131 company-owned and 116 franchised stores in the United States, Puerto Rico, Canada, Hong Kong, Singapore and Australia.

The nine Michigan Chuck E. Cheeses are part of 12 family-operated franchised stores owned by Little Caesars pizza parlor owners Mike and Marian Ilitch. Mike Ilitch also owns the Detroit Red Wings.

Unlike other Pizza Time restaurants around the country, the Ilitch stores are holding their own, according to franchise attorney Denise Ilitch-Lites.

Lisa Ilitch, the franchises' marketing and public relations director, would not release sales or profit figures, but she said sales have jumped 30 percent in the most recent quarter from the last quarter of 1983, and weekly patronage has remained about the same as during the industry boom year of 1982.

BUT ELSEWHERE, the chain's problems appear to be more severe. Pizza Time president and chief executive officer Henry Montgomery promised last week to return the company to profitability, but he faces a number of hurdles in achieving that goal.

While Pizza Time officials were well-versed in the entertainment industry, they did not have expertise in the restaurant industry, said New York restaurant analyst Hardy Bowen, of the investment firm of Arnhold and S. Bleichroeder Inc. “They did not have the discipline to run a restaurant,” he said. “The salad bars are sloppy, operations are bad, and a lot of the restaurant fundamentals were poor.”

The pizza, which was the mainstay of the restaurant, was considered bland by some and not good enough to draw adults, who could care less about singing robot dogs and Pac-Man.

“Had they been selling good pizza at the same time they were selling theatrics, it would have made the customer base more stable,” said restaurant analyst Charles Glovsky of Eppler, Guerin & Turner Inc., a Dallas-based investments firm.

Ilitch-operated franchises use their own pizza recipe, which is not the same as Little Caesars' pizza, but much better than Pizza Time's, Lisa Ilitch said.

Because of the seemingly unlimited growth potential of the Chuck E. Cheese format, similar restaurants popped up all over the landscape and started to cut into each other's market.

In Dallas, where there are nine of the Pizza Time type restaurants, the market is saturated, Glovsky said. “Every time they opened a new store, they were cannibalizing the sales of the old stores,” he said.

K mart dropped out of the industry because of a rapid trend away from arcade video games and toward home entertainment systems. “Why go out when you can order a pizza . . . and play at home?” said K mart's Palazzolo.

Pizza Time managers also are under pressure to come up with new robots and routines to keep customers satisfied, Lisa Ilitch said. “Kids get tired of things fast, so you have to keep changing,” she said.

Finally, with a cost of up to $1 million to outfit a store, it is not easy to attract the sales volume necessary to make a profit, Bowen said.

In an effort to salvage what once promised to be a lucrative business, the industry has made changes.

Within the last six months, Pizza Time has instituted a heartier pizza with more sauce and lounges with wide-screen televisions to appeal to adult customers, a spokesman said.

ShowBiz Pizza has adjusted its robotic entertainment to feature Beatles music to appeal to parents. The firm also has started testing short-subject films.

Lisa Ilitch traces the relative success of the Ilitch-owned franchises to the fact that the family has been in the restaurant business for 25 years and that they have added some unique innovations.

To create a greater adult market and offer more variety, pasta dishes, Mexican food and sandwiches have been added to the menu in Clawson and are expected to be offered at the other stores, she said.

The firm's Clawson restaurant also features new rides and six computer-controlled robots capable of tapping their feet, rocking in rocking chairs, and talking back to children with the help of a technician in a hidden control booth.

THE NEW ROBOTS were built specifically for the Ilitch-owned stores and will likely be featured in their other stores, Ilitch said.

“We wouldn't be changing (parts of the operation) if we weren't planning to stay in business. The concept of Chuck E. Cheese will never die. Parents always need somewhere to take their little kids.”

Paul Pendergast, a Dallas-based spokesman for ShowBiz Pizza, said, “We think the marketplace is improving for a survivor. We intend to be a survivor and perhaps the only survivor. ”

But analyst Bowen said the industry is trendy, and he does not think the entertainment restaurant/theater concept will continue to attract customers.

“The longer they are open, the lower the volume,” he said. “About the eighth time (a customer returns), those robots get a little old.”

[Photo caption] A young fan watches the robot trio at the Chuck E. Cheese Pizza Time Theatre in Clawson.